This is the film I'd been waiting for most all year long, and I would say that it did fulfill my expectations. I had checked out writer/director/Frenchie Coralie Fargeat's previous breakthrough film, REVENGE (2017), which was a completely over-the-top, ultra-violent revenge thriller that felt like what you would get if you took the energy of the darkest Hard Summer Festival EDM tracks and adapted them into a horror-ish film. I don't think I've seen any other noteworthy films that felt so "EDM-drenched", outside of maybe Harmony Korine's SPRING BREAKERS; the main difference being that Korine did it in an entirely tongue-in-cheek way, while Fargeat's "living dubstep" vibe feels primarily sincere - typically I would think this would be a bad thing, but somehow with Fargeat it works and feels very right - perhaps it's one of those things that only a French person could get away with.
Once I heard how intense The Substance was supposed to be, and how many people "couldn't handle it" at its initial screenings, along with the synopsis, intriguing cast, and seeing who the director was, I felt very certain the world was about to have something of great note in its hands. I must say that I am a bit surprised just how many people seem to be in love with this movie, when it's so extreme. To me, it mostly blends Extreme French Horror with pure exploitation and, of course, body horror, but in the bigger picture, what it really feels like is the epitome of a B-movie that somehow managed to get made and widely released with an A-list cast and A-level production value. Of course, for me, these are all wonderful things. I'd say this is the greatest B-movie to be released since MANDY in 2018, and it joins a very small group of contemporary B-movies which manage to transcend all elements of cheapness that make most B-movies precisely that, and win over a larger audience.
It seems obvious to say this is an entirely unexpected and astonishing comeback role for Demi Moore. Who would have imagined an A-list actress gone for so long would make her return to the big screen after raising multiple daughters and having her legendary husband turn to a vegetable, in the most extreme and disturbing movie to see a wide release in years? I mean, at times The Substance almost feels like a BASKET CASE sequel. It has to take a lot to mentally commit to something like this. While I think the Oscar nod talk I've heard mentioned around her performance is a bit of wishful thinking, I do find her performance entirely worthy of celebration - she pulls no punches, and, man, her character goes deeper into an abyss than 99% of film characters could ever dare. While her performance was grade A, I would say that only Willa Fitzgerald's performance in Strange Darling is one that reaches a level worth noting above everyone else, this year. Considering Margaret Qualley is one of my favorite actresses overall at the moment, her involvement had me stoked from the start, and added much to enjoy throughout the entire film. Her umbrella of films is quite fascinating at this point, just as it's fascinating that she is allowing herself to become this staple of some sort of frighteningly hyper-sexual archetype. It's funny how her mom freaked out over how "crude" Drive Away Dolls was at the beginning of the year, then her dad was on his way to see Kinds of Kindness with a group of friends, and she told me him to turn around and not watch it. Can you imagine how they felt when they watched The Substance?!?!?! I think one of them might implode. This is probably her most lascivious role yet, aside from maybe SANCTUARY - though I'm a massive fan of the majority of her roles, I've gotta say SANCTUARY still takes the cake as her finest performance, but she is unabashedly diving headfirst into near-pornographic territory in The Substance, and it's very wild. Dennis Quaid was also perfect in this.
Without spoiling anything, I've enjoyed how polarizing the final act of this film has been. While some have said that it was the only part that didn't work for them, a greater quantity have stated the final act is precisely what elevated the film to be a new favorite for them. To me, the final act is exactly what the movie needs. While it was absolutely not what I was expecting, tonally, I welcomed it with a massive smile (while trying not to be fully removed from the finale as my girlfriend ran out of the auditorium amidst an anxiety attack during the ultra-violent "chase scene", and stayed outside for the last 25 minutes of the film). While I found the first 2/3 of the film to be rather repetitive in structure, it's not a bad thing as I believe that is how this story needed to be told. Much like Enter The Void, it is more of an experience you must live (or survive) through, rather than simply a story you are being told in chapters. The final act really breaks the formula up, and wraps things up in a glorious blast of hyper stimulation that is not often seen in movies this century. And, it really shines a light on how much nuanced humor is meant to be underlying through the majority of the movie that precedes it. I could never refer to this as a dark comedy - it is far too brutal for that, but it definitely has plentiful elements of humor. It really is quite a singular film; while the closest I could get to anything is like combining all of Frank Hennenlotter's movies (Basket Case, Frankenhooker, Brain Damage, and Bad Biology) with old school Cronenberg (The Fly, Videodrome, eXiSTeNz), but honestly, even that can't quite encapsulate what The Substance "has done". The only way one can understand what The Substance has to offer is by seeing it.
8 out of 15 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends