MIL.12.Q1.W2. Reponsible Use of Media and Information
MIL.12.Q1.W2. Reponsible Use of Media and Information
Grade 12
JOANNE P. PATING
Developer
JOANNE P. PATING
Developer
RESPONSIBLE USE OF MEDIA AND INFORMATION
II. OBJECTIVES
At the end of the lesson, the learners should be able to:
1. reflect if one is a responsible user of media and information;
2. analyze and evaluate an issue (news report) about plagiarism; and
3. discuss the responsible use of media and information using different
platforms (video, infographics, etc.).
III. INTRODUCTION
We deal with a lot of information out there. Among the many challenges that we face
is managing the vastness of information. While we address these needs, knowledge of
ethical standards related to information literacy will also guide us to be responsible user of
media and information.
Plagiarism is using other people’s words and ideas without clearly acknowledging
the source of information. The Republic Act 8293 or Intellectual Property Code of the
Philippines clearly states the right of the authors to be recognized.
However, Common Knowledge refers to facts that can be found in numerous places
and are likely to be widely known need not to cite the source. Example: John F. Kennedy
was elected President of the United States in 1960. This is generally known information. You
do not need to document this fact
You must document facts that are not generally known, or ideas that interpret facts.
Example: Michael Jordan is the greatest basketball player ever to have played the game.
This idea is not a fact but an interpretation or an opinion. You need to cite the source.
When you use a direct quote, place the passage between quotation marks, and
document the source according to a standard documenting style. Example: According to
John Smith in The New York Times, “37% of all children under the age of 10 live below the
poverty line”. You need to cite the source.
Even when using someone’s ideas, but rephrasing them in your own words. Although
you will use your own words to paraphrase, you must still acknowledge and cite the source
of the information.
While ideas themselves are not copyrightable, the artistic expression of an idea
automatically falls under copyright when it is created. Under fair use, small parts may be
copied without permission from the copyright holder. However, even under fair use - in which
you can use some parts of the material for academic or non-profit purposes - you must
attribute the original source. What is considered fair use is rather subjective and can vary
from country to country.
2
TYPES OF PLAGIARISM
There are different types of plagiarism. Learning to recognize the various forms of
plagiarism, especially the more ambiguous ones, is an important step in the fight to prevent
it. Plagiarism can still happen either sources are cited or not cited. Let’s take a look how by
studying the following.
SOURCES NOT CITED
1. “The Ghost Writer” 2. “The Photocopy”
The writer turns in The writer copies
another’s work, word- significant portions of
for-word, as his or her text straight from a [Link]
inion/columns/photocopying-
own. [Link] single source, books-for-students-copyright-high-
court-3075857/
resume/
without alteration.
3. “The Potluck Paper” 4. “The Poor Disguise”
The writer copies from The writer has
several different altered the paper’s
sources, tweaking the appearance slightly
sentences to make by changing key
them fit together while [Link] words and phrases. [Link]
s/10-potluck-etiquette-rules- ements-Fuzzy-Glasses-Classic-
retaining most of the 2374604/ Disguise/dp/B000JNS2ZS
original phrasing.
5. “The Labor of 6. “The Self-Stealer”
Laziness” The writer “borrows”
The writer takes the generously from his
time to paraphrase [Link]
or her previous work.
most of the paper 07/06/proverbs-69-11-failing-to-
instill-a-daily-discipline-of-study-
from other sources and-labor-in-your-child-allows-the-
laziness-of-a-sluggard-to-become- [Link]
and make it all fit a-predictable-path-to-poverty-and-
together. sorrow-2/
SOURCES CITED
1. “The Forgotten 2. “The Misinformer”
Footnote” The writer provides
The writer mentions inaccurate information
an author’s name for a regarding the sources,
source, but neglects making it impossible to [Link]
to include specific [Link] find them. nocchio-for-ipad-
iphone/id422133774?mt=8
11/08/12/forgot-to-register/
information on the
location of the
material referenced.
3. “The Too-Perfect 4. “The Resourceful
Paraphrase” Citer”
The writer properly The writer properly
cites a source, but [Link] cites all sources,
neglects to put in to-craft-the-perfect-lawyer- paraphrasing and using
[Link]
quotation marks on quotations [Link]
photo/young-man-holding-many-
text that has been appropriately. The books_857159.htm
3
WHAT ABOUT IMAGES, VIDEOS, AND MUSIC?
[Link]
Using an image, video or piece of music in a work you have produced without
receiving proper permission or providing appropriate citation is plagiarism. The following
activities are very common in today’s society. Despite their popularity, they still count as
plagiarism.
1. Copying media (especially images) from other websites to paste them into your
own papers or websites.
2. Making a video using footage from others’ videos or using copyrighted music as
part of the soundtrack.
3. Performing another person’s copyrighted music (i.e., playing a cover).
4. Composing a piece of music that borrows heavily from another composition.
The legality of these situations, and others, would be dependent upon the intent and
context within which they are produced.
The following are safest approaches to take to avoid plagiarism. Through these, you will
be applying ethical ways of using Media and Information.
4
Now, that you are done understanding plagiarism, understand also how to be a
responsible user of Media and Information aside from avoiding plagiarism. The following
are the characteristics of a responsible media and information used.
[Link]
2. Critical thinker
[Link]
3. Wise
We see a lot of information on the internet.
Some are in appropriate to our age, some are catchy
and informative. But turned out to be scam or fake
news. As a media literate, we must know how to act
responsibly. Hide or report information that is
offensive and inappropriate. Don’t just click or share
unknown links for it might steal your personal
information. Also, be efficient information manager!
[Link]
5
Privacy is power!
Hurt (legs) – don’t be hurtful towards others.
Being online doesn’t mean less hurtful than in
personal. It’s the same!
[Link]
Take note, producers and users of media and information may have the following purposes:
1) To inform; 4) To advocate;
2) To educate; 5) To promote business; and
3) To entertain; 6) To increase network.
While it can be argued that standards of behavior may be different in the virtual
world, they certainly should not be lower. The following are the Core Rules of Netiquette to
remind us of our manners in the virtual world. ([Link]
Rule 2: Adhere to the same standards of behavior online that you follow in real life.
You should do your best to act within the laws and ethical manners of society
whenever you inhabit "cyberspace." Would you behave rudely to someone face-to-face?
6
Rule 6: Share expert knowledge.
The Internet offers its users many benefits; one is the ease in which information can
be shared or accessed and in fact, this "information sharing" capability is one of the reasons
the Internet was founded. So in the spirit of the Internet's "founding fathers," share what you
know! When you post a question and receive intelligent answers, share the results with
others. Are you an expert at something? Post resources and references about your subject
matter.
Rule 7: Help keep flame wars under control.
"Flame wars” is when two or three people exchange angry posts between one
another. This must be controlled or the camaraderie of the group could be compromised.
Don't feed the flames; extinguish them by guiding the discussion back to a more productive
direction.
Rule 8: Respect other people's privacy.
Depending on what you are reading in the virtual world, be it an online class
discussion forum, Facebook page, or an email, you may be exposed to some private or
personal information that needs to be handled with care. Perhaps someone is sharing some
medical news about a loved one or discussing a situation at work. What do you think would
happen if this information "got into the wrong hands?" Embarrassment? Hurt feelings? Loss
of a job? Just as you expect others to respect your privacy, so should you respect the
privacy of others.
Rule 9: Don't abuse your power.
Just like in face-to-face situations, there are people in cyberspace who have more
"power" than others. They have more expertise in technology or they have years of
experience in a particular skill or subject matter. Maybe it's you who possesses all of this
knowledge and power! Just remember: knowing more than others do or having more power
than others may have does not give you the right to take advantage of anyone. Think of Rule
1: Remember the human.
7
ACTIVITIES
Activity 1: Reflect
Instruction: Write your answer on the space provided. Your answer should have atleast
5 sentences but not more than 10 sentences.
Read the following articles below on a case of plagiarism or you may watch Saksi:
Exclusive: UP Graduate Student na Nag-plagiarize ng Litrato sa mga Contest, Nag-
sorry. YouTube Channel: GMA News and Public Affairs Uploaded September 24, 2013 from
[Link]
First Article:
UP STUDENT PLAGIARIZES PRIZE-WINNING PHOTOS
University of the Philippines graduate student Mark Joseph Solis made the confession
when Rappler contacted him by phone on Sunday, September 22.
"I'm deeply sorry. I'm in deep remorse. Right now, I already contacted the organizers and
8
I'm about to contact the owner to personally convey to him my deepest and personal apology,"
Solis said.
According to posts on the "Narinig ko sa UP" (Overheard at UP) Facebook page, Solis had
done this at least 5 times since 2011.
The most recent photo that Solis claimed to be his won the top prize in the Smiles for the
World photo contest conceptualized by Chilean Ambassador Roberto Mayorga.
It came under intense scrutiny on social networks on Sunday after the real owner of the
photograph, Gregory John Smith, revealed how "an impostor... abused my copyright."
Solis submitted a photo of a boy whom he said was named Nilo and was from Zamboanga
City. The caption stated that the boy helped his father farm seaweed.
During Chile's National Day on Wednesday, September 18, at the Cultural Center of the
Philippines, Solis was awarded $1,000 and roundtrip tickets to Chile and Brazil.
Smith, a social entrepreneur, said the photo belonged to the Children at Risk Foundation,
which he founded. The child in the photo was from Brazil, not Zamboanga City, he said.
Smith posted a comment on a recent feature article on the ambassador claiming ownership
of the photo.
Smith pointed to his Flickr account, which contained the same photo – taken in 2006 –
along with other photos of children in Brazil. The photo was titled, "Neptune, King of the Sea."
Solis is a political science alumnus of UP and is currently taking up his Masters in Public
Administration at the National College of Public Administration and Governance.
The website of the International Association of Political Science Students said Solis is a
legislative staff of Senator Pia Cayetano.
Cayetano tweeted Sunday, "To those asking, Mark Solis was a probationary staff for three
months. He has not been connected with our office since June."
It wasn't the first time Solis joined and won a contest using photos taken by other people.
Solis sent Smith's photo to the United Nations International Year of Water
Cooperation contest. The caption stated this time that the child was from India, according to posts
on the Narinig ko sa UP page.
Another photo he entered into the same contest was also from the Children At Risk
Foundation's Flickr album.
In 2011, he also entered and won the first Papworth Trust's photo competition. The owner
of the photo is a Flickr user who took the photo in 2008.
The Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process, which also held a photo
contest in 2011, received a false entry from Solis as well. The original photo, also found on Flickr,
even had a watermark on it.
Disappointed
9
Mayorga told Rappler he only wished to show appreciation on the Calidad Humana of the
Filipinos. He added that he hopes this does not tarnish the image of all Filipinos.
"The majority [of Filipinos] have plenty of Calidad Humana," Mayorga told Rappler,
"Unfortunately, these kind of exceptions are the risk you have in your nice country. This shows it is
necessary to take care of your good people, preserving among them the positive elements of their
personality."
Mayorga said that they will conduct an investigation into the matter. But he warned that
Solis' conduct may forfeit his award.
Solis said he will meet with the contest organizers on Monday. – [Link]
[Link]
2. What sanctions did he receive from the organizing committee? Describe his
actions.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
3. Do you think technology and the internet have made plagiarism easier? Do
you think technology has made people more or less creative? Explain your
answer by citing examples.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
Second Article:
UP GRAD IN PHOTO PLAGIARISM GETS REDEMPTION
Janvic Mateo (The Philippine Star ) - December 2, 2015 - 9:00am
MANILA, Philippines - For former Chilean ambassador to the Philippines Roberto Mayorga,
Mark Joseph Solis more than just redeemed himself: he has proven that the dark moments in one’s
life often reveal the brightest trait of an individual.
For the past two years, Solis, a graduate of political science from the University of the
Philippines, managed a football program for street children at a makeshift field inside the Baclaran
church compound in Pasay City.
10
The football club, with players aged eight to 12, seeks to develop children’s character
through the sport.
“We were inspired by the world-class football players of South America who started via
street football,” Solis, who co-founded the program, said in an earlier report in The STAR.
“But more than developing top athletes, we aim to provide these kids with opportunities for
personal and spiritual development,” he added.
The program was part of his commitment to Mayorga and the rest of the people behind the
Calidad Humana project following a photo plagiarism controversy that hounded the Smiles for the
World photo contest sponsored by the embassy of Chile in 2013.
Solis was stripped of the grand prize after it was learned that he was not the person who
took the winning photo. He later apologized for the incident.
Mayorga, meanwhile, asked him to participate in the activities of Calidad Humana as part
of his path to redemption.
“I think this is very important,” Mayorga told The STAR following the book launch of
“Calidad Humana: Sharing the Filipino Spirit” at the Cultural Center of the Philippines yesterday.
“Mark Solis is an example that it is possible for someone to redeem himself, to change,” he
added.
Mayorga, now a consultant for the Energy Development Corp. (EDC), said the issue is now
closed as Solis has genuinely repented and redeemed himself following the incident.
“Two years working with children, and now he’s a different person,” Mayorga said.
For the former ambassador, the lessons Solis learned from one of most challenging
episodes in his life are more important.
“He was so damaged, totally damaged,” he recalled, adding that Solis has worked hard to
recover from the aftermath of the controversy. “After fulfilling his commitment, he deserves to be
recognized.”
Mayorga and Solis shared an emotional embrace at the culmination of the book launch as
the latter’s “redemption” from the controversy was imparted to the audience.
Solis, who has suffered harsh criticisms on social media over the plagiarism case, declined
the request for an interview, saying he is now “living a quiet life.”
He, however, pledged to continue working with the program to promote Calidad Humana, a
Filipino value loosely translated as kabutihang loob sa kapwa (goodness to fellowmen).
During the book launch, Mayorga stressed the need for Filipinos to recognize and preserve
an exceptional trait of “deep and intuitive concern for others that comes naturally to Filipinos.”
“A majority of Filipinos are known for their positive attitude: friendliness, hospitality,
humility, the priority they give to others over material things, resiliency, spirituality, joy of life and a
sincere attitude. This is calidad humana,” he said.
The book contains articles that provide the intellectual framework aimed at understanding
and strengthening the concept. It also contains numerous messages from various notable
individuals from different sectors.
“Sometimes a country is best seen through the eyes of a foreigner. That is the case with
11
Roberto Mayorga, Chile’s former ambassador to Manila,” STAR editor-in-chief Ana Marie
Pamintuan wrote.
“(Calidad humana) is exemplified, he says, in the smile that comes easily to the Filipino,
even in the midst of poverty and adversary… This book is a tribute to the Filipino spirit,” she added.
Oscar Lopez, chairman emeritus of the Lopez Group of Companies, wrote the foreword to
the book.
“Together, we need to do our utmost to safeguard, preserve and cultivate this national
spirit. But we should also be aware as Filipinos that our calidad humana can be our gift to the world
and that it is both a privilege and responsibility to share,” Lopez wrote.
“Just as all countries seek to export their natural resources or their industrial and
technological products, the Philippines is in a unique position to export its human richness to all the
peoples of the world,” he added.
Foreign Affairs Undersecretary Laura del Rosario, who attended the book launch, said the
department would distribute copies of the book to the different Philippine consulates and
embassies to spread the word on calidad humana.
Mayorga said a second part of the book, which will cover different ways on how Filipinos
can safeguard calidad humana, would be released next year.
[Link]
1. According to the article, how did Solis redeem himself? What job did he
have?
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
12
V. RUBRIC FOR SCORING
The following are the criteria in grading your performance task output. This will serve as
your guide as you create your output.
Needs
Good (4
Criteria Excellent (5 POINTS) Fair (3 POINTS) Improvement (2
POINTS)
POINTS)
Content The required Learning One of the Two of the The required
• Learning competencies is required required learning learning
Competencie achieved. Learning competencies is Competencies is
s for competency is missing or not not achieved.
Information missing or not achieved.
Literacy. achieved.
• Relevance of All pictures are related to 1-2 pictures are 3-4 pictures are 5 or more
the pictures the topic and made it not related to the not related to the pictures are not
easier to understand the topic. topic. related to the
message or content. topic.
Overall Quality Outstanding skill in Good skill in Adequate skill in Poor attempt at
• Creativity Showing imagination and showing showing utilizing
and creativity in content and Imagination and imagination Imagination and
Production production techniques. creativity in And creativity in creativity in
Techniques content and content and content and/or
production production production
techniques. Techniques. techniques.
Citations or Reference list is evident Reference list is Reference list is Reference list is
References and all borrowed evident but evident but 2 or missing.
• Reference materials are cited. 1borrowed more borrowed
List material is not materials are not
cited. cited.
TOTAL
13
VII. REFERENCES:
Alagaran II, Jose Reuben Q. Media and Information Literacy: Empower the Disccerning Audiences.
Quezon City. ABIVA Publishing House, Inc. 2017
Andres, Virginia P., Plaza, Louis Mark N., Rotor, Conrado C., Vilbar, Aurelio P., Villanueva, Cheryl F.
Teaching Guide for Senior High School Media and Information Literacy. Quezon City. The Commision
on Higher Education. 2016
GMA News and Public Affairs. Youtube Channel: Saksi- Exclusive: UP graduate student na nag-
plagiarize ng litrato sa mga contest, nag-sorry. September 24, 2013.
[Link] (accessed July 23, 2020).
Gonzales, Edward D. Media and Information Literacy. Pasay City. JFS Publishing Services. 2016.
Liquigan, Boots C. Media and Information Literacy. Makati City. Diwa Learning System Inc. 2016.
What’s More
Activity 1: Essay
Answers vary
Activity 2: Case Study
Answers vary. Sample answer are found below
14