Kimber Silver's Reviews > The Merchant and the Alchemist's Gate

The Merchant and the Alchemist's Gate by Ted Chiang
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
92166434
"Coincidence and intention are two sides of a tapestry, my lord. You may find one more agreeable to look at, but you cannot say one is true and the other is false."

And so I entered the world of Fuwaad ibn Abbas, a merchant from Baghdad, who by coincidence (or intention) stumbles upon a wondrous metalsmith’s shop.
Bashaarat, the store owner, cordially greets Fuwaad. As he peruses the fascinating items on display, the craftsman casually mentions that he has something even more fantastic in the next room. Would Fuwaad like to see this extraordinary object? He wondered.

"Of course he would!" I exclaimed. "Take us to see this magical marvel at once!" My anticipation was electric, sparking like a molten blade in the process of being forged.

The clanging of metalwork faded into the background as Bashaarat spoke of his discovery — a gateway of seconds. He then stepped up to a metal hoop positioned chest-high in the middle of the room and gave a demonstration.

“Bashaarat thrust his arm through the hoop from the right side, but it did not extend out from the left. Instead, it was as if his arm were severed at the elbow, and he waved the stump up and down, and then pulled his arm out intact.
I had not expected to see such a learned man perform a conjuror's trick, but it was well done, and I applauded politely.
"Now wait a moment," he said as he took a step back.
I waited, and behold, an arm reached out of the hoop from its left side, without a body to hold it up. The sleeve it wore matched Bashaarat's robe. The arm waved up and down, and then retreated through the hoop until it was gone”


Fuwaad and I were both skeptical, but our curiosity was piqued, and we were eager to unravel this mystery.

The metalsmith shared with the merchant that there was more.

How could there be more? I pondered as I hurried after the two men as they entered another chamber. A large, polished metal circle waited silently — a gateway of years…

This is the best short story I’ve read this year! The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate is a brilliant tale that left me mesmerized. Take an hour to visit Bashaarat’s emporium. You’ll be glad you did.

Many thanks to my Goodreads friends for pointing the way to this terrific tale.
It’s free to read HERE.
99 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Merchant and the Alchemist's Gate.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 14, 2024 – Started Reading
September 14, 2024 – Shelved
September 14, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
September 15, 2024 –
95.0%
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: cautionary-tale
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: classic
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: epic-reads
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: family-drama
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: fables
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: favorites
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: hope
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: humor
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: magical-realism
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: magic
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: longing
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: loss
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: must-read
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: second-chances
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: short-stories
September 16, 2024 – Shelved as: splendid-writing
September 16, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Axl Oswaldo (new)

Axl Oswaldo Beautiful review, Kimber.
I must read this story ASAP, I’m intrigued now. :)


Kevin Ansbro Delighted that you also enjoyed this magical piece of escapism, Kimber. Fab review!


Cheri I'm so glad that you picked this one up to read, it's such a wonderful story with that sprinkling of a magical essence, and reading your lovely review made my day!


Maureen Beautiful review Kimber, thanks for the link.


Kimber Silver Axl Oswaldo wrote: "Beautiful review, Kimber.
I must read this story ASAP, I’m intrigued now. :)"


Thanks so much, Axl! I think you'll enjoy this. I look forward to your review! : )


Kimber Silver Kevin wrote: "Delighted that you also enjoyed this magical piece of escapism, Kimber. Fab review!"

Thanks to your brilliant review, I did indeed! Thank you for the link and your kind words, Kevin! : )


Kimber Silver Cheri wrote: "I'm so glad that you picked this one up to read, it's such a wonderful story with that sprinkling of a magical essence, and reading your lovely review made my day!"

Thanks very much, Cheri! It was a magical tale and so well done. I enjoyed your fab review as well. : )


Kimber Silver Maureen wrote: "Beautiful review Kimber, thanks for the link."

Thank you so much, Maureen! You're welcome. I hope you enjoy it too! : )


message 9: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Chiang is a talented author and it comes as little surprise you enjoyed this. Have you read The Story of My Life which was adapted to a film titled Arrival starring Amy Adams?


message 10: by Catherine (new)

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - why is GR broken? -_- And free to read? Sounds fabulous! :) Thanks for the heads-up on this one, Kimber!!


Kimber Silver Jonathan wrote: "Chiang is a talented author and it comes as little surprise you enjoyed this. Have you read The Story of My Life which was adapted to a film titled Arrival starring Amy Adams?"

I haven't read The Story of My Life. Thank you for the recommendation, Jonathan!


Kimber Silver Catherine wrote: "And free to read? Sounds fabulous! :) Thanks for the heads-up on this one, Kimber!!"

It is a spectacular short story! I hope you enjoy it, Catherine. You're welcome! : )


Mark  Porton Magical review Kimber!! I reckon ALL OF US would love to see this extraordinary object. Would you? More importantly would you leap through it?

I would :))


message 14: by Barbara (new)

Barbara "Best of the year says it all, Kimber. Lovely and convincing review.


Kimber Silver Mark wrote: "Magical review Kimber!! I reckon ALL OF US would love to see this extraordinary object. Would you? More importantly would you leap through it?

I would :))"


Thank you, Mark! I loved your review for this one.
Yes! I would leap! ; )


Kimber Silver Barbara wrote: ""Best of the year says it all, Kimber. Lovely and convincing review."

This was such an engaging read. Thank you very much, Barbara!


Vanessa M. Great review, Kimber! I'm so glad you too enjoyed it!


Kimber Silver Vanessa wrote: "Great review, Kimber! I'm so glad you too enjoyed it!"

Thanks so much, Vanessa! Once I started reading, I was hooked. : ) I'm glad to see all the stars from you as well.


switterbug (Betsey) Kimber, lovely review, and thank you for providing the story, too!


message 20: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer nyc Your review was so compellingly written, I was disappointed to find that it's a short story, Kimber! I have his collection and hope to get to it. Thanks for the link :)


message 21: by Fran (new)

Fran Kimber...an exemplary review!


Kimber Silver switterbug (Betsey) wrote: "Kimber, lovely review, and thank you for providing the story, too!"

Thank you, Betsey! You're welcome! I hope you enjoy this magical tale, too. : )


Kimber Silver Jennifer wrote: "Your review was so compellingly written, I was disappointed to find that it's a short story, Kimber! I have his collection and hope to get to it. Thanks for the link :)"

Thanks, Jennifer! It was a delightful read. I look forward to your thoughts. You're welcome!


Kimber Silver Fran wrote: "Kimber...an exemplary review!"

Thank you kindly, Fran! : )


message 25: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Shindler Great review, Kimber. Thanks for sending the story our way.


message 26: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna Beautiful review, Kimber. And what high praise that it is the best short story you have read this year. Thanks for the link, added!


Kimber Silver Daniel wrote: "Great review, Kimber. Thanks for sending the story our way."

Thanks so much, Daniel! You're welcome! : )


Kimber Silver Lorna wrote: "Beautiful review, Kimber. And what high praise that it is the best short story you have read this year. Thanks for the link, added!"

Thank you very much, Lorna! It was a spectacular read. I hope you enjoy it too!
You're welcome. : )


Tina(I can only make 10 comments! Man!) Wow! That's a lot of praise as the best story all year! Thanks for the link Kimber. A wonderful review! ✨


message 30: by Kat (new)

Kat I love a good magical story. This sounds enchanting! Great review, Kimber 🩷


Kimber Silver Tina wrote: "Wow! That's a lot of praise as the best story all year! Thanks for the link Kimber. A wonderful review! ✨"

This was a glorious short story. You're welcome. I hope you enjoy it, too.
Thank you, Tina! : )


Kimber Silver Kat wrote: "I love a good magical story. This sounds enchanting! Great review, Kimber 🩷"

Enchanting is a perfect word, Kat! Thank you kindly! : )


message 33: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Great review! 🧡


Kimber Silver Mary Beth has lots of catching up to do! wrote: "Great review! 🧡"

Thank you, Mary Beth! : )


message 35: by Jonas (new)

Jonas Wonderful review. You really captured the reading experience. I read this one in his collection Exhalation and really enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing where to find it for free!


Kimber Silver Jonas wrote: "Wonderful review. You really captured the reading experience. I read this one in his collection Exhalation and really enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing where to find it for free!"

Thank you so much, Jonas! It is a magical short story, and I'm glad you enjoyed it, too.
You're welcome! : )


Shelley's Book Nook Beautiful review, Kimber. 🤗💕


message 38: by Kimber (last edited Oct 02, 2024 04:54AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kimber Silver Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Beautiful review, Kimber. 🤗💕"

Thanks so much, Shelley! : )


message 39: by Nilanjana (new)

Nilanjana Haldar It is a truly mesmerising story, I couldn’t agree more with your beautiful review, Kimber friend


Kimber Silver Nilanjana wrote: "It is a truly mesmerising story, I couldn’t agree more with your beautiful review, Kimber friend"

Thank you so much, Nilanjana!🙏 I'm glad you enjoyed this terrific tale, too!😊


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Fabulous review Kimber 💖


Kimber Silver Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up wrote: "Fabulous review Kimber 💖"

Thank you very much, Margaret! : )


Laysee Superb review, Kimber. Thank you for the link to this enticing tale.


Kimber Silver Laysee wrote: "Superb review, Kimber. Thank you for the link to this enticing tale."

Thank you kindly, Laysee! You're welcome. I hope you enjoy it too. : )


message 45: by Peter (new)

Peter That was a beautiful review, Kimber, you brought the book to life.


Kimber Silver Peter wrote: "That was a beautiful review, Kimber, you brought the book to life."

Thank you very much, Peter! It's nice to see you here. :-)


back to top